Creative vision contains a playful quality. — John Briggs
One can be serious about the frivolous,
frivolous about the serious. — Susan Sontag
Few working artists would argue the point that making art on a regular basis is serious work. Certainly many artists think of it that way. The obstacles, real and imagined, one must confront over time are legion, and we are not static systems; our temperaments and physical abilities of course oscillate by nature. But few also are the artists who would argue that somewhere along the line, at least some particle of play is not a necessary element in the process.
How sharply we define the areas in which play is invited into our process varies from artist to artist. For some, play is allowed only a brief appearance when structures have been attended to and a new direction must be found (upon which to build a new set of structures). For others, the entire process is as play-like as possible, even unto the media, and more rigorous attention to form comes only later.
A notable quality as intrinsic to the one kind of play as it is to the other is that in order for play to exist, even in its most anemic form, it must be free of judgment. This is not to say that characters or aspects within the play itself can’t exhibit judgment, if that is the form the play takes, it is rather that the larger mental space in which the play is allowed to exist must be at least temporarily free of judgments regarding our ordinary rules of behavior and thought and form.
I use that idea in my toolkit of techniques to cut through creative blocks. Creative blocks, often couched in the armor of plausible deniability, righteous authority, and a harsh “realism,” are almost always serious, grim, heavy. Play is light, spirited, and free. How can I take the former and instill the qualities of the latter? If my mood is grim enough — and when judging my work my mood can get grim indeed — then the main danger is that I’ll dismiss applying playful ideas outright. Who wants to play if they’re feeling grim? To work my way back to a state of play, I have to go one step deeper and pull back from my immediate situation.
We have to, if only as a thought experiment, put the kibosh on judgment in this situation. Judgment quelches play. If I’m blocked, if work is not getting done, there is usually an underlying thought that the work, or at least the element I’m currently trying to introduce, is wrong, even bad.
Sometimes, if I take some time out and carefully examine the train of thoughts that led me to this place, this mode of rejection, I can find a thought, a judgment, I accepted without much scrutiny, some idea based on some passing fearful belief (sometimes of artistic inadequacy of some kind, sometimes based on — totally false — imaginings of how the work will be recieved), upon which I, without thinking, based all the subsequent thoughts. And every thought that came after, often running only in the background of my mind, as I considered the work in front of me, finally brought me to this place of disliking everything I add to the work — all of which branched out from that one shaky, fearful, judgmental thought.
These are the chimaeras out of which creative blocks are made.
I reintroduce the willingness to play by realizing that the structures and beliefs by which I delimit my own actions as I create art are all artificial, and are all either created or accepted by me. If I’m at a point where I’m too frozen by my own judgment to lay elements freely onto the piece I’m working at the moment, I simply need to remember the reality.
Rules are guidelines, not absolute truth.
Back up. There are things I like about the piece — what are they? Add or don’t add, but do no harm to those. It’s good to reach, but if my highest goal is not attainable, I need to realize I have elements of this piece I like, and that can be enough for this piece. There will be others.
At ANY given moment there are a thousand artists around the world throwing elements at their medium with abandon, with wildness, with freedom, with a spirit of play. Sometimes when I let myself get wrapped up in rules or self-created negative premises — widely accepted or self-created — I forget that essential reality.
Self-check: Am I tired? Hungry? Low on resources? If so, step back, take care of it, regroup, and come at it later. Late in the work day when we’re low on resources, gremlins appear. Don’t let them run amock.
The creation of something new is not accomplished by the intellect but by the play instinct acting from inner necessity. The creative mind plays with the objects it loves. — Carl Jung
If we have become too serious about our work, and this is resulting in blocks, we need to discover the levers that will allow us to bring at least a wisp of the spirit of play back into our process. A famous rock singer I’ve heard of retires to an adjacent room in the studio to watch Monty Python — methods that suit you will occur to you when you give it some thought. Build a toolkit of techniques. Beware the sandtraps of artificial rules, low physical resources, and judgment. Giving frivolity some serious consideration, as Sontag suggests, can help you keep your creative process light and flowing, and give you helpful methods to avoid the pitfalls that can slow down and stop the work.
Be well.
13 comments
Comments feed for this article
July 10, 2009 at 1:25 pm
Dee Wilcox
You do an amazing job bringing to light the philosophical and unconscious approaches we take to creativity. Sometimes it takes someone saying, “Hey, you are judging your work, evening harming elements of it, and that is contributing to the creative block you’re facing.” We often don’t think of our art, or of our creative flow, in that way – as something that should be nurtured.
When I am blocked in my “work” work, I introduce creative play by breaking out analog tools I haven’t used in a long time – like clay, glue and paper, etc. Or, I go to a local craft store and see what new and unique tools have come out, and I contemplate how I might use them. I typically bring home a few new tools or supplies and play with them. Sometimes these “play” sessions translate to my work; however, more often than not, they help me break through my work block, and I find myself with new thoughts and ideas later that day or the next.
July 10, 2009 at 2:53 pm
abrooklynartist
Thank you, Dee! That’s a really great approach, I love the “analog tools” idea. I think it probably translates to all variety of media. The processes we use can seem very personal and unique to us, but I think some of these blockbuster ideas, at their root, can be applied across the board if one can just spend a little time and seek out the levers. Thank you for sharing your insight. Cheers!
July 20, 2009 at 7:16 am
winnie
Thanks so much for this awesome articles and quotes on twitter. This site was blocked in China until recently I found a way to unblock it. I just opened it today and had the chance to read.
What you just said reminding me of what my teacher used to say that art is devotion, not about skills, that the boringest paintings are all painted by trained hands,while anyone’s first sincere attempt on painting is fascinating to look at.
July 21, 2009 at 10:53 am
abrooklynartist
Winnie, hello! I’m delighted you are enjoying the blog and the Twitter quotes! That’s a beautiful way to put it, that one’s art practice is a “devotion.” I like that very much. I hope you are doing well over there in China. A beautiful country but I have not had the chance yet to visit. Cheers and thanks again! Come over and comment anytime. 🙂
July 22, 2009 at 7:19 pm
Belly Acher
Thanks also for the great Sontag quotation…
July 23, 2009 at 12:36 am
abrooklynartist
She’s truly great. Cheers!
July 27, 2009 at 7:56 pm
CarusoPhoto
Fantastic post! You’ve touched on points I’ve long held to be true. Freeing the mind with play is an integral component of the creative process. Without it, we wither.
Thanks so much for putting these ideas out there!
July 27, 2009 at 9:45 pm
abrooklynartist
Really nice of you, thank you for that. Like your blog a lot; nice work! Hope you don’t mind I put a link to it in mine. Cheers!
August 5, 2009 at 1:14 pm
stills in transit
another thoughtful and thought-provoking post. looking forward to others.
February 16, 2010 at 6:49 pm
smockyboods
I really like when people are expressing their opinion and thought. So I like the way you are writing
February 21, 2010 at 2:24 pm
abrooklynartist
Thank you both very much. Right now my energies are going into a book on the subject. Cheers!
March 26, 2010 at 6:15 am
chiefjester
Awesome post with wonderful quotes. I look forward to hearing more about the book!
May 9, 2010 at 8:32 pm
abrooklynartist
Thanks a lot! The book is almost done. Some minor rewrites — after multiple drafts, mind you — and then it’s off to be typeset. Cheers and thanks again!